Kayla Nicole, sports journalist and ex-girlfriend of NFL star Travis Kelce, set the internet ablaze this Halloween by recreating Toni Braxton’s legendary look from the “He Wasn’t Man Enough” music video — and fans believe there’s more to the costume than meets the eye.
The former ESPN reporter and influencer shared photos of her stunning transformation on Instagram, donning a leather outfit and short haircut that perfectly mirrored Braxton’s 2000 R&B era. But it wasn’t just her resemblance that caught everyone’s attention — it was the song choice.
Toni Braxton’s hit “He Wasn’t Man Enough” is famously about a woman warning another about a man’s unfaithful past. Social media immediately erupted with speculation that Kayla’s Halloween look was a subtle jab at her ex, Travis Kelce, who is now dating pop superstar Taylor Swift.
💬 Fans React
Online users flooded her comments with fire emojis and theories.
“She knew exactly what she was doing,” one fan wrote.
“Kayla understood the assignment!” another added.
Meanwhile, Swift fans weren’t as amused — some accused her of trying to “stir drama” just as Taylor and Travis’s relationship continues to dominate headlines.
🎃 Celeb Support and Shade
Adding more fuel to the gossip fire, Odell Beckham Jr.’s ex-girlfriend Lauren Wood appeared to “like” Kayla’s post — a gesture fans interpreted as a show of support amid the online chaos.
Still, many praised Nicole’s creativity, saying her Halloween tribute to Toni Braxton was one of the best celebrity recreations of the year.
Taylor Swift Engaged to NFL Star Travis Kelce After Two Years Together
✨ A Message or Just Style?
Kayla has not directly responded to the speculation, keeping her caption light and simple — but her timing and choice of inspiration have left social media divided. Whether intentional or not, she reminded everyone that she’s not afraid to make a bold statement through style.
🧠 FAQs About Kayla Nicole’s Halloween Costume
1. Who is Kayla Nicole?
Kayla Nicole is a sports journalist, model, and social media personality. She’s best known for her past relationship with NFL player Travis Kelce and her popular online presence.
2. What was Kayla Nicole’s Halloween 2025 costume?
For Halloween 2025, Kayla Nicole dressed as Toni Braxton from the 2000 music video “He Wasn’t Man Enough”, complete with the singer’s iconic short haircut and edgy leather outfit.
3. Why do fans think the costume was a message to Travis Kelce and Taylor Swift?
Because the Toni Braxton song she referenced is about a man who wasn’t faithful, many fans believe Kayla was subtly shading her ex, Travis Kelce, and his new partner, Taylor Swift.
4. Has Kayla Nicole said anything about the rumors?
No, Kayla hasn’t commented directly on the speculation. She shared her costume with a simple caption and has stayed silent as fans debated her intent.
5. What was the public reaction to her costume?
Reactions were mixed — some praised her creativity and confidence, while others viewed it as shade toward Travis and Taylor. Overall, her post went viral and became one of Halloween’s most talked-about celebrity moments.